Thoroughly researched and clearly presented, Law's Alabama Brigade is a valuable addition to the historical body of ACW unit histories. This is clearly a study that is first rate in its historical method. This work distinguishes itself with its attention to detail in describing the evolution of unit politics (which persisted throughout - and even after - the war) and the personal histories of men who served in this brigade. The descriptions of the battles engaged by these five regiments prior to their consolidation as an all-Alabama brigade under Evander Law is disappointing (especially Gaines Mill, Second Manassas and Antietam). However, the passage concerning the approach and assault on Devil's Den and Little Round Top on the second day at Gettysburg is superb. The treatment of the brigade's battles at Chickamauga and in the Wilderness is also excellent. Of great interest is the relation of events surrounding the political and personal feud between Evander Law and James Longstreet (both South Carolinians but evidently not compatriots) which was never resolved. Insight into Longstreet's political nature (foreshadowing his conduct after the war) and Lee's allegiance to Longstreet (despite his personal misgivings) is offered in convincing fashion. Penny and Laine do not possess the literary skills to make their work into a compelling story for the average reader, but for students of the ACW, this is a first rate work and a fascinating read.